Hemant Rohera on sizing supercapacitors for minimum weight: what sets the mass of the bank in twelve applications
Preprint, version 1.0, Zenodo, 11 October 2026 · doi:10.5281/zenodo.23301485 · CC BY 4.0
A supercapacitor bank weighs what its cells weigh, so the sizing step decides how heavy a hybrid storage system is. In my new paper I size the bank for each application the earlier Hybrid Power Pack papers identified, from a 12 V engine start to a ship-to-shore crane, and ask one question of each: what actually sets the weight?
The method: size for the last day, not the first
Every bank is sized at the end-of-life values its datasheet defines: capacitance 20 % lower and ESR 100 % higher than new. A search over seven datasheet-verified EDLC cells then returns the lightest bank that still meets the event energy, the power, the voltage window and, for repeated duty, a temperature-rise limit. Every input is labelled as sourced, computed or assumed.
The results: three regimes
| Application | Cell mass | What sets the size |
|---|---|---|
| Engine cranking, 12 V | from 1.44 kg | ESR: 4.3–5.8× the capacitance energy alone requires |
| 10 kW fuel-cell step | 3.6 kg (60 in series) vs 14.4 kg (240 in series) | Series count sets a mass floor |
| Battery-electric car, WLTC | 30.6 kg | Battery Joule heat 26 % lower |
| Battery-electric car, US06 | 61.6 kg | Battery Joule heat 54 % lower |
| Metro wayside store, 353 kW for 12.3 s | 470 kg (233 kg as a lithium-ion capacitor) | End-of-life allowance, 26.5 % of the mass |
| Ship-to-shore crane, 9,152 kJ cycle | 1,426 kg | ESR: 2.1× the capacitance energy alone requires |
Peak-power events are governed by resistance, so a low-ESR cell is worth more than a high-capacitance one. Repeated energy events are governed by the event size and the ageing allowance, and heat trades against life: 10 % more cell mass lowers the ageing factor from self-heating by 19 %. Small events on a high-voltage bus hit a floor set by how many cells it takes to span the voltage.
For a battery-electric car, the best return per kilogram comes from a small bank behind a 5–10 s low-pass split. For photovoltaic smoothing, a low-pass split at τ = 20 s gives 1.1 t of cells per MWp for a 9.2 % lower battery peak power. Both point the same way: the capacitor takes the fast part of the duty, the battery the slow part.
All results are computed from stated inputs, not measured. The analysis also appears as Chapter 10 of the consolidated monograph. A manuscript based on this preprint has been submitted to the Journal of Energy Storage (Elsevier) for peer review. I am the named inventor of the Hybrid Power Pack patents (US 10,523,019 B2 and family).
Read the paper: Zenodo, doi:10.5281/zenodo.23301485 · web version with summary table · all publications on Google Scholar
Companion papers: Two Stores, One Power Pack (physics) · The Hybrid Power Pack as a Platform (claim-by-claim engineering) · the consolidated monograph.
Comments
Post a Comment